Twin Test: Two Identical Golfs, One Bought From a Dealer, One From a Bloke Named Dave
Photo: user:AngMoKio, CC BY-SA 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons
The Great Used Car Experiment
There are two camps in the used car world, and they argue like Arsenal and Spurs fans. Camp one says buy from a dealer: you pay more, but you get consumer rights, a warranty and someone to shout at when the gearbox falls out. Camp two says buy privately: pay less, take the risk, pocket the difference.
We got bored of the arguing and decided to settle it properly. The rules were simple. Find two identical used cars — same model, same age, similar mileage — one from a franchised dealer, one from a private seller. Buy both. Run both for three months. Tally everything: purchase price, fuel, repairs, insurance, admin, and the sheer number of phone calls each one generated.
Our weapons of choice: a pair of 2016 Volkswagen Golf 1.6 TDI SEs, both silver, both with around 70,000 miles on the clock. One from a main dealer in Milton Keynes, one from Dave. Dave lives in Nuneaton, sells the occasional car from his drive, and describes his Golf as "sweet as a nut," which in the private sales lexicon means absolutely nothing and everything.
Round One: The Money
The dealer Golf cost £9,750. It came with a 12-month warranty, a fresh MOT, a valet so thorough the car smelled of vanilla, and a salesperson called Ross who said "lovely car, this" eleven times in one viewing.
Dave's Golf cost £8,200. It came with half a tank of diesel, a boot full of child-related debris, and Dave's verbal warranty: "If anything goes wrong in the first month, give us a bell."
That £1,550 gap is the headline number. On paper, private wins. But this was a three-month test, and paper has a habit of catching fire.
Round Two: The Paperwork and the Phone Calls
Buying from the dealer was frictionless. Tax handled, part-exchange declined politely, finance politely declined less politely, keys in hand within 48 hours. Total phone calls: three.
Buying from Dave required more legwork. HPI check (£19.99, and worth every penny), a pre-purchase inspection at a local garage (£90, also worth every penny — it flagged a weeping rear shock the dealer's car didn't have, which became our negotiation lever), and the slightly nerve-wracking process of handing over £8,200 via bank transfer while Dave's dog barked at the postman. Then the V5C had to arrive, the tax had to be sorted, and the insurance had to be amended mid-afternoon on a Wednesday. Total phone calls: seven, plus one awkward follow-up to Dave about the rear shock. He sent us £60 and a box of Celebrations. Genuinely.
Round Three: What Went Wrong
The dealer Golf, naturally, behaved itself for the first six weeks. Then the DPF light appeared. Under the warranty, it was diagnosed and fixed at no cost — a sensor, four days in the workshop, a courtesy car that was somehow a larger Golf. Cost to us: zero pounds, one day of hassle.
Dave's Golf needed the rear shock doing (£85 fitted, after we'd already negotiated £60 off the asking price for it — Dave's Celebrations softened the blow but didn't cover it), then a failed rear brake light bulb, then an advisory for a perished front tyre at the MOT. The dealer car sailed through its MOT with one advisory for a slightly corroded rear bracket.
By the end of three months:
- Dealer Golf: £9,750 purchase, £0 repairs, 1 warranty claim, 3 phone calls
- Dave's Golf: £8,200 purchase, £145 repairs, £19.99 HPI, £90 inspection, 7 phone calls, 1 box of chocolates
Total cost including incidentals: £9,783 for the dealer car versus £8,494 for Dave's. The private car still wins on money — by roughly £1,290 — but the gap has closed from £1,550 to £1,290, and Dave's car needed actual effort from us.
The Verdict: Who Actually Wins?
Here's the thing nobody in the trade tells you: the dealer premium isn't just profit, it's insurance against your own optimism. If you're the kind of person who doesn't know a DPF from a dipstick, that £1,300 buys you a safety net, a warranty and someone to blame. That's not nothing.
But if you can arrange an independent inspection, run an HPI check, and stomach the driveway experience, buying privately still comes out ahead financially — even after the repairs, the admin and the dog. The catch is that you are the warranty. When something breaks, it's your money and your Saturday morning at the garage.
Our advice? Buy privately if you're buying something mainstream, common and cheap to fix — the Dave Golfs of this world. Buy from a dealer if you're stretching your budget, buying something complex or exotic, or you simply don't want to think about cars between services.
And if you do buy from a bloke named Dave, check the rear shocks. And accept the Celebrations. They're part of the deal.